Selected Studies

CNA Resource Analysis Publications

March 31, 2013

This briefing is designed to assist Marines considering the choice between a High-3 retirement and a REDUX retirement with a $30,000 Career Status Bonus. For virtually every Marine, choosing REDUX/bonus results in a significant loss in retirement income over the course of a Marine’s lifetime.

Read More | Download Report
March 31, 2013

Military personnel who entered service after July 31, 1986, and who are eligible and intend to serve for 20 years must choose between two retirement plans at their 15th year of service. Once the final selection is made, the choice is irrevocable. How should Marines, Sailors, Airmen, and Soldiers decide which option to take? The Department of Defense (DOD) has a website that provides information and examples to help servicemembers. We have used a different approach that many have found useful in evaluating these retirement choices. Here, we update that work for those making the retirement choice in 2013.

Read More | Download Report
October 31, 2012
The Center for Information Dominance’s Center for Language, Regional Expertise, and Culture (CLREC) plays a central role in training Department of the Navy personnel in the language skills and cultural knowledge required to effectively carry out their missions. CLREC turned to CNA to provide feasible options for providing feedback from customers after mission performance, instead of immediately after predeployment training (the current process).
Read More | Download Report
September 30, 2012
The right of the federal government to reuse, modify, reproduce, perform, display, release, and disclose data - particularly computer software - has become an important topic in contract negotiations. We describe the valuation methods used by DOD and industry to estimate software development costs and to assign value to data rights licenses that are broader than the default license described in DFARS. We find that the benefit to DOD arises from the impact of such licenses on future competition and costs. Two things must occur for expanded licenses to be worth the additional cost to DOD: the additional information covered by the license must be transferrable to alternative suppliers, either competing commercial companies or organic DOD facilities. Second, the information covered by the license must be useful to alternative suppliers, to the extent that it actually lowers their production costs.
Read More | Download Report
July 31, 2012
In this paper, we examine the continuation behavior of prior-service (PS) Marines in the Marine Corps Selected Reserve (SelRes). We use Marine Corps Total Force System (MCTFS) data on Marine officers and enlisted Marines who left active duty and affiliated with the SelRes between October 2001 and April 2011 to look at how long Marines tend to affiliate with the SelRes and which Marines are most likely to leave the SelRes at any given point in their SelRes careers. We estimate the effects of Marine characteristics and service history (active duty and reserve) on PS Marines’ decisions to leave the SelRes separately for never-activated and activated Marines.
Read More | Download Report
June 30, 2012
In this paper, we examine the Selected Reserve (SelRes) affiliation behavior of prior-service (PS) Marines. We use Marine Corps Total Force Structure (MCTFS) data on enlisted Marines and Marine officers who left active duty and transitioned to the Individual Ready Reserve (IRR) between October 2001 and September 2011. We estimate the effect of Marine characteristics and service history (active duty and reserve) on the SelRes affiliation decisions.
Read More | Download Report
June 1, 2012

This briefing is designed to assist Marines considering the choice between High-3 retirement and a REDUX retirement with a $30,000 Career Status Bonus.

Read More | Download Report
June 1, 2012

Military personnel who entered service after July 31, 1986, and who are eligible and intend to serve for 20 years must choose between two retirement plans at their 15th year of service. Once the final selection is made, the choice is irrevocable. The two options are the High-3 retirement plan and the REDUX retirement plan plus a $30,000 bonus paid at the 15th year of service.

Read More | Download Report
May 1, 2012

In this memo, we look at an obvious but seldom discussed implication of climate change for installation managers: rising temperatures and their implications for installation energy use.

Read More | Download Report
April 1, 2012

The unemployment rate, an oft-cited labor market statistic, is reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) for veterans and nonveterans.1 Popular press, including the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times, often compares the veteran unemployment rate with the overall national unemployment rate as a way to characterize the civilian economic prospects of veterans.

Read More | Download Report
February 1, 2012

This report assesses the costs and benefits that would result if the Navy were it to substitute lump-sum Selective Reenlistment Bonuses (LSSRBs) for its current program of anniversary payment SRBs (APSRBs). Our analysis suggests that adopting LSSRBs would likely result in significant savings over the long term, even accounting for the possibility of increased losses. We also find that the policy change could have substantial non-monetary costs and benefits: adopting LSSRBs would result in the SRB program being easier to manage when the economy is contracting, but more difficult to manage when the economy is expanding.

Read More | Download Report
December 1, 2011

Achieving the desired overall force composition in the Navy requires accessing the right mix of recruits—enlisted and officer, active and reserve. To do this, the Navy must have details about the available recruitable population, including where specific types of people are located. The Commander of Navy Recruiting Command (CNRC) asked CNA to help improve the methods and models which currently geographically allocate recruiting goals. NRC uses econometric models to guide to allocate goals for recruiting enlisted personnel, and employs a less rigorous method for officers.

Read More | Download Report
November 1, 2011

Although in recent years non-citizens have made up only a small share of enlisted accessions (roughly 4 percent), they are a potentially valuable pool for enlisted recruiting

Read More | Download Report
November 1, 2011

The Marine Corps Fitness Report (FitRep) system provides the official evaluation and record of an officer’s performance. Given the FitRep’s importance in determining fair and equal opportunity for career progression and continuation, it is crucial that the system be reviewed periodically. The Marine Corps implemented the current FitRep system in 1999 to address concerns about grade inflation, and the system has not received a thorough examination since then.

Read More | Download Report
March 31, 2011

.A review of the power demands of U.S. military installations asking the questions:

• Could nuclear power plants contribute to DoD missions?
• What are the significant issues related to safety, certification, licensing, construction, and operations?
• Could a nuclear power plant on a military installation be constructed and operated in a cost effective manner?

Read More | Download Report
March 1, 2011

The free flow of oil is critical to world commerce and global economic prosperity. Oil trade requires the use of maritime trade routes, which can span from hundreds to thousands of miles. Hence, oil tankers often travel through straits and canals to reduce transport costs. These passageways—referred to as chokepoints—are narrow channels along the most widely used global sea routes.  This study evaluates how potential disruptions at critical chokepoints could affect the U.S. economy and economies around the world.

Read More | Download Report
February 1, 2011

Military personnel who entered service after 31 July 1986 and who are eligible and intend to serve for 20 years must choose between two retirement plans at their 15th year of service. Once the final selection is made, the choice is irrevocable.

Read More | Download Report
November 15, 2010

How will climate change affect military humanitarian and disaster response operations? Answering this question requires answering a number of other, related, questions. How will climate change affect the frequency, type, and nature of disasters and humanitarian emergencies? How will pressures from climate change affect social and economic factors that determine the security situation at the scene of the response? What types of disasters do US military forces respond to today, and how do they compare with those types of disaster most affected by climate change? Why does the US commit military forces to a disaster response operation? And what unique capabilities do they bring when they arrive?

Read More | Download Report
November 1, 2010

In anticipation of Congressional action to require all federal facilities to have advanced electric meters “to the maximum extent possible,” the Navy needs to determine the most cost-effective way to comply with this requirement.

Read More | Download Report
October 29, 2010

This annotated briefing analyzes the last 30 years, trying to answer the following questions: Have recruit characteristics changed over time? Have the relationships between recruit characteristics and subsequent attrition remained stable or have the patterns changed? What characteristics are most important for predicting success in the Corps? While most of the focus is on accession characteristics and bootcamp attrition, we also look at first-term attrition and long-term retention.

 

Read More | Download Report
September 15, 2010

The relationship between education credentials and first-term attrition rates in the military is well established. Enlistees who lack a traditional high school diploma have first-term attrition rates that are 40 to 50 percent higher than those of high school diploma graduates. This research explores the relationships between AIM scores, other personal characteristics, and military performance.
 

Read More | Download Report
March 1, 2010

At their 15th year of service, military personnel who are eligible and intend to serve for 20 years must choose either: (1) High-3 retirement plan or (2) A reduced retirement (REDUX) and a $30,000 bonus paid at the 15th year of service. This paper is designed to help servicemembers make that decision.

Read More | Download Report
June 1, 2009

We investigated the personnel inventory that would be necessary to meet the Navy’s manpower requirements for the 313-ship Navy. We find that at any time over the 30-year shipbuilding plan, the Service’s immediate manpower requirements could be satisfied with an endstrength of only 322,000. However, we estimated that the Service’s minimum viable long-term personnel inventory will be between 332,000 and 334,000.

Read More | Download Report
June 1, 2009

This manual describes the use and maintenance of the Personnel Inventory Aging and Promotion (PIAP) model and discusses its development, structure, and outputs. Additionally, the manual provides guidance for interpreting the model’s results.

Read More | Download Report
April 30, 2009

CNA was asked to review the changing situation in the Arctic and to assess the operational implications for the Navy of the potential increase in maritime activity.

Read More | Download Report